Planning Before Demand Is Known: The Airline Problem Behind OpenSky’s Dice
An airline cannot wait until every passenger has decided to travel before planning its schedule. Aircraft and routes need to be organised in advance, while future demand remains uncertain.
This is a different problem from choosing the best plan after the outcome is known. OpenSky captures that difference by asking players to build a network before the Passenger Dice reveal the markets they will compete for.
A forecast is not a guarantee
In their 2005 MIT presentation Dynamic Airline Scheduling, Hai Jiang and Cynthia Barnhart describe planning from forecasts and available resources, with demand variability leaving some flights short of customers while others face demand above capacity.
The enduring issue is that a plan can be well reasoned and still encounter an unfavourable outcome. A forecast helps choose a deployment; it does not remove the uncertainty that follows it.
Flexibility has value before you need it
Consider two fictional network plans. One is excellent for a single expected market. The other is less concentrated but can serve several possible O&Ds. Which is preferable depends on how likely those markets are, what each can earn and how costly adjustment would be.
This is a scenario question. Instead of asking only what happens if the forecast is right, ask what happens if demand appears elsewhere. There is no universal rule that broader coverage wins: spreading resources too thin can create weak itineraries or expose the airline to stronger competition.
How uncertainty shaped OpenSky's sequence
In OpenSky, Network Planning comes before the monthly Marketing Phase. The dice generate airport callsigns, and the player rolling them chooses the month's origin and destination from the available results.
That sequence means you commit capacity without knowing every future market. Network flexibility matters because the opportunity to bid depends on whether your airline can form a valid itinerary when a market appears.
The dice do not simulate an airline forecasting department
Real demand is not literally generated by a handful of airport dice. Airlines have booking information, historical patterns and other evidence. OpenSky compresses uncertainty into a visible event, rather than asking players to build a forecasting model.
It also gives the rolling player a choice between the revealed airports. This is a game decision, not a claim that one real airline controls where all passengers want to travel.
After an unlucky round, separate the quality of your plan from the result. Did it cover useful possibilities? Did it depend on one narrow outcome? Could a competitor invalidate the itinerary? Those questions tell you more than judging the entire network from a single roll.
Discover OpenSky and try the airline decisions around the table. For the complete gameplay details, read the OpenSky rules.