Why Nonstop Flights Can Command a Premium—and How OpenSky Captures It

Two airlines offer the same destination. One flies nonstop; the other requires a change of aircraft. Even when the connecting ticket is cheaper, some passengers will still choose the nonstop. They are comparing more than the fare.

The extra time and inconvenience of a connection are part of the product. That gives a well-positioned nonstop service a competitive advantage, although the size of that advantage varies between markets and passengers.

The price of a journey includes time

A 2019 working paper by Ennen, Allroggen and Malina, studying US domestic markets, found higher average willingness to pay for nonstop service. Its model also examined the role of stopovers, flight time and transfer time in the attractiveness of connecting itineraries. This is evidence from a particular study, not a universal premium that can be applied to every route.

The practical idea is straightforward: a lower fare may need to compensate for a less convenient journey. How much compensation is enough depends on the traveller and the alternatives available.

A connection can still be a strong competitor

A connecting airline does not need to offer an identical product to compete. It can serve an O&D through an existing network and offer a price that makes the extra stop worthwhile. A passenger with flexible time may make a different choice from someone who needs to arrive for a particular appointment.

For the airline, this creates a positioning question. Should it defend the convenience of its nonstop service, or reduce its fare to discourage customers from accepting a connection? The answer cannot come from comparing fares alone.

How the nonstop advantage shaped OpenSky's competition

OpenSky gives this trade-off a clear rule: a one-stop itinerary can beat a competing nonstop itinerary only when its fare is half of the lowest competing nonstop fare or less.

That threshold is a game rule, not an estimate of real passenger behaviour. Its purpose is to make the convenience advantage matter during bidding. The cheapest numerical bid is not automatically the strongest offer when the itineraries differ.

It also links pricing back to network planning. A useful nonstop route gives you a kind of competitive protection. A connection can reach more markets, but may need to make a substantial price concession to win against direct competition.

The decision to try at the table

Before bidding, compare the journeys. If you have the nonstop, decide whether your network advantage supports a higher fare. If you have the connection, check whether your available cards can satisfy the discount requirement. Building an itinerary and pricing it are two parts of the same decision.

Discover OpenSky and try the airline decisions around the table. For the complete gameplay details, read the OpenSky rules.

Back to blog

Sharing my experience at AIRFRANCE, LUFTHANSA, SKYSCANNER, TRIVAGO and many other travel companies with all #AVGEEKS and their friends!

Meet the founder